WATCHING PEOPLE’S reactions to the themes in the movie House has been interesting. The film as a whole is deeply influenced by everything from cinematography to acting to direction to score to special effects…the list is endless, and the end product was way beyond my control. But the story on which the movie is based was mine and reviewers’ reaction to the basic theme of that story interests me.
They fit into three broad categories that look something like this:
First, there are the Christian reviewers who act as so-called experts on the value of a film, a quantity they derive by scoring negatives and positives. Like mathematicians using formulas, the more analytic among them give the end product either a thumbs up or a thumbs down. For many of these, House wasn’t Christian enough.
Then there are the hosts of Christians thrilled to see something hit the screen that isn’t blatantly Christian. As long as the theme is fairly plain, the mere absence of an overt Christian message draws cheers from them. In their view, House was just about right.
Finally, there are the non-Christian reviewers. Reading their opinions, you might think House was blatant propaganda designed to shove the church down the audience’s throat. In their view, House was far too Christian, nothing short of an evangelical sermon.
So which is right? It all boils down to expectations, really. What people expect from a movie or a book, profoundly impacts their interaction with it.
Throughout my career I’ve often found myself in the cross-hairs in this regard. There is always significant pressure on me from the minority Christian machine to produce more “Christian Friendly” stories. This amounts to material that fits more nicely in exclusively “Christian” sectors of the market, and runs little or no risk of offending anyone for any reason. Even better, novels that are blatantly Christian.
This is a huge market, a fact of which I am well aware. Millions gobble up books of this ilk. The Christianity is direct, the message spoon fed, and the sales are high. I have no argument against writers who choose this route, but I have chosen another.
In his essay on “Christian Apologetics,” C.S. Lewis made a statement that guides my writing. He reasoned that an argument for Christian principles or truth might hold people’s attention as they are reading it or hearing it, but
“the moment they have gone away from the lecture hall or laid down our article, they are plunged back into a world where the opposite position is taken for granted. Every newspaper, film, novel and textbook undermines our work….”
He then went on to say,
“what we want is not more little books about Christianity, but more little books by Christians on other subjects—with their Christianity latent.”
Lewis makes the point that, for the most part, blatantly Christian books only feed the faithful with quickly forgotten lessons while they are rejected by the rest of the world. Many Christian books are written for commerce, to sustain a self-feeding machine that benefits few. It’s easy, it’s profitable, it’s seen as honorable by many.
But, I made the choice to follow the advice of Lewis. In his words:
“Our business is to present that which is timeless in the particular language of our own age,” he said. The “bad” writer “does exactly the opposite: he takes the ideas of our own age and tricks them out in the traditional language of Christianity.”
This is why I use contemporary story forms and modern mythic structures to flesh out my characters’ search for the truth. It’s also why my characters don’t stop in the middle of the story to tell the readers they are reading a “Christian” story. In fact, they aren’t. Citing Lewis’ admonition, my publisher, Allen Arnold of Thomas Nelson, has always strongly encouraged me along this path. Nevertheless, the pressure to fit into a status quo is always looming and sometimes feels like a strong head wind.
One reviewer asked of House, “A Christian horror movie? Isn’t that, like, impossible? What do they do, say ten Hail Marys while they’re hacking up each other?”
While this was said tongue in cheek, it points to society’s tendency to compartmentalize, and it seems the world has sequestered Christianity into a small box that resembles little of what my peers and I believe. Following Lewis’ idea, it would be a mistake to call our works Christian, making them “one more little book (or movie) about Christianity” because any book labeled as “Christian” is assumed to essentially be “about Christianity” as was clearly the case with the reviewer above.
House isn’t any more or less Christian than Narnia. Neither was The Matrix. Nor are Black, Red, and White. Nor, for that matter, Adam and Thr3e, Saint and BoneMan’s Daughters. They are all about characters thrown into extraordinary circumstances, searching for significant meaning which comes with the discovery of truth. Does this make them “Christian?” Lewis would probably say no. Yet all of my novels are infused with hope. Their worldview is saturated in redemptive history.
Oddly enough, the pressure to be more overtly Christian seems to be motivated as much by money as by principle. Pioneers always pay a price, just ask Luther and Tyndale. The established Christian machinery is as much about business models as principles, but that’s another blog altogether.
Meanwhile, you tell me, should I write “one more little book about Christianity?” Or should I do what I’ve always done as recommended by Lewis: Tell stories in “the language of our own age” on other subjects with my “Christianity latent?”
i definitly think you should tell stories in “the language of our own age” on other subjects with your “Christianity latent”.
i am going to see the movie when it comes out on DVD with my non-christian friend. hopefully she will see the face of God that day. just wanted to tell u to keep on SHREDDING THE NAR!!!! ….
in case you didn’t know that means sharring you faith in unique but intresting ways
ohh i was talking about HOUSE by the way
All I can say on the subject is this: The subtlety in your writing never ceases to amaze me, and the lessons your novels teach have stuck with me far more than they would’ve had they been blatantly obvious. I really must agree with you and C.S Lewis. And now, I must continue trolling the blog. =)
I adore the way you write and strongly encourage you to continue following C.S. Lewis’ advice. It is brings more effective stories and is much more original. Wade through the deep waters of criticism and eventually you will arrive at the glorious gates of Heaven and have gifts showered upon you.
I just watched the long awaited “House” movie. I must admit I was a bit confused by the ending. I was wondering, what makes this movie stand out from the rest of the horror genre movies? There was nothing that represented a power that could overcome the power of darkness unless you accept the notion that an evil-looking character that seems to encourage not falling for the illusion (which can easily be killed itself) could somehow produce a light that ?fried the bad guy. I was confused by what exactly the light came from. Was it the psychic lady down the road? Was it the other side of the force? Was it the power of ?God whatever you consider that to be? Could someone shed a little light (no pun intended) on this situation?
YO DEKKER, MY FRIENDS AND I MADE A VIDEO ABOUT YOUR BOOK, CHOSEN, FOR OUR SCHOOL NOVEL PROJECT. IT IS ON YOUTUBE, UNDER Chosen school project. CHECK IT OUT, IT’S AWESOME.YOU ROCK!
I read your CNN interview today and was puzzled by your statement that you don’t have any Christians in your stories. I’ve been a big fan since the Circle trilogy came out. I’ve read nearly everything you’ve written since then and am also going back and reading some of your older books. I just finished When Heaven Weeps today. When I read that quote, I thought immediately of Father Michael and Nadia. And then of Thomas Hunter and several others who experience an encounter with Christ (or a representation of Him), and find salvation by grace through faith in His sacrifice on their behalf. I guess I’m curious as to what you meant. Characters like Nadia and Father Michael, I would think, are Christians in the truest sense of the word. Again, I’m a huge fan. I mean no criticism but am sincerely asking. Thanks for your great work.
Could someone list a book/compilation that contains the essay on “Christian Apologetics” of C.S. Lewis? I will never cease to be amazed at how fresh and relevant Lewis’ sentiments are today. I would like to read the essay that those quotes were taken from.
Thanks,
Matt
found it… “God in the Dock”
Keep on doing what you are doing! You have got it right. That’s why we keep reading! I don’t want another happy ending, perfect little story. I want real, “dive deep” stories that touch my soul and lead me to God. Don’t let all the nonsense get you down!! Listen to your fans…and there are tons of us!!
the reason i read your books is because they are the way they are, you are an incredible writer and you refuse to write what people want you to write, you write on your own terms..
if every writer wrote what made the whole world happy all the books would be the same, or there would be no books at all.
I love what your doing!!
you are a constant inspiration, i am a young-unknown-small town writer who writes for her own pleasure and the pleasing of God.
your views and writing are amazing!
House was a life changing book.
heh… when i was reading the Circle trilogy, i was on my way to a retreat with my friends from Church. after asking the standard questions like “what are you reading?” and “is it interesting” (don’t see the point of asking the latter question – if i am holding a huge book in my hands – i was reading the three-in-one edition – and i am half done with it, why ask if it is interesting? O_O anyhow)… the next question was “what is it about?”
“it’s a Christian thriller…” i said.
without waiting for me to proceed with my description, they all exclaimed, surprise evident in their voices, “a Christian thriller???? how can that be?”
i took a deep breath and explained that “a thriller is what thrills. not necessarily scares you. the book is ultimately about Love, courage, choices, and more Love.”
but i guess they still did not understand how can i read something like that. *sigh*
nevertheless, i told my non-believer friend about “this book that i just LOOOOVED” and she was interested in reading it. after starting it, she asked whether it has something to do with Christianity. i said that it has the elements, but it’s not a Christian book. now i am waiting for her comments when she’ll be done with the Circle.
sorry to be so long-winded. it’s just that it’s interesting how it seems that most of the Christians want, as Max Lucado put it, “pre-chewed spiritual food.”… and thanks for not going into that area.
I love your idea’s, I loved the book house, I am looking forward to seeing the movie, I was sort of hoping it would come out again.
I will use your approach with my writing teachers, he let me know my writing was too christian for him [Public College]. Maybe it will help my grades.
i loved house! book and movie! the movie lacked some of the finer freakyness of the book but it relayed the message. speaking of movies, when is blink of an eye going to be a movie? on the cover it says “based on the upcoming motion picture”. i would love to see it!
Hey…..nice post!!
Awesome, No more words to explain
just….cool blog.
I had a dream to begin my own business, however I didn’t earn enough amount of money to do it. Thank goodness my close friend proposed to take the business loans. Thence I received the secured loan and realized my old dream.
Truly appreciate this particular publish. It’s difficult to organize the nice from the bad sometimes, but I think you have nailed it! Me and also my buddy were arguing about an issue clone of this! Now I know that I was right. lol! Tkank you for that info you publish.
I think Lewis had it right. Go for it. And with the genius contained in your blogs and other ” non fiction” stuff, I think you could extremely successfully write a book that is not a story, per say. Like some of Lewis’s books that you mentioned. And as you said, not necessarily about Christianity, but from Christianity (not the “American Christianity”) and about life. A suggestion:)I love your words and stories by the way. They’ve inspired me alot, and revealed truths I knew, but not in words.
Amen, Ted!
We need more writers who happen to be Christians like you out in the world.
Keep writing how you write. In “the language of our own age” on other subjects with your “Christianity latent”. I love your books and have learned so much from them.
We need more writers who happen to be Christians like you out in the world.
e writers who happen to be Christians like you out in the world.
The content of your blog is exactly what I needed, I like your blog, I sincerely hope that your blog a rapid increase in traffic density, which help promote your blog and we hope that your blog is being updated and placed can always be richer and more colorful.
There is noticeably a bundle to learn about this. I assume you made sure nice points in features also.
earn about this. I assume you made sure nice points in features
I’ve been following your web site for some time now and finally, I decided to write this post in order to thank you for providing us such a fine content!!!
acupuncture pain is believed to have originated from ancient China with evidences tracing dating back to the Stone Age. Ancient medical practitioners used Bian shi or sharp stones similarly to today’s needles. Archaeological findings revealed that stone acupuncture needles have existed since 3000 B.C. Similar practices were found in Eurasia throughout the Bronze Age along with other countries like Mongolia, Japan and Central Europe.
http://www.shoptoryburchs.com
I feel strongly though, that although drugs could be a necessity initially, taking them long-term is quite like taking out the batteries from your smoke detector whenever your home is burning!
Stoltenberg would not comment on the investigation or the possibility of another attack, though he noted that there would come a time to look into how police responded to the violence.CHI Straightener
I will invite all my friends to your blog, you really got a great blog.
Hi there,Really nice job,There are many people searching about that now they will find enough sources by your tips,Also looking forward for more tips about that
Republican Representative Mick Mulvaney, a supporter of the Tea Party movement that demands even deeper spending cuts, said he still would vote against the bill as he left Boehner’s office to pray at the congressional chapel
That was interesting.I like your quality that you put into your post.Please do continue with more like this.
Do not seek to follow in the footsteps of the men of old; seek what they sought.
In fact, no matter how they dress, they appear cute, good-natured and charming. They are not very hard to choose a bridesmaid dresses. Jewelry will be better correlated with the mother of the bride a -Line wedding dresses, but not for girls. They better be nice and nature. Also, flower girl prom dresses can have a wide variety of colors available.
Great tips, I would like to join your blog anyway,
All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts. Thanks
After reading this article ,make my eyes open .And this article make me impressve.
In a word ,I agree with this article.
tile outlet
To get to travel a put that not only has quite a lot of famous value, still is usually a by natural means gorgeous terrain, check out Yemen. A lot of holidaymaker destinations set this catch of catering their own civilization as well as towns towards travelers, locations want Yemen which have been off the overwhelmed way can be splendid to look. Cheers a good deal.
Since the recognise displays, cheap handbags will be maintain by way of your hands as a result of their own small strap
What a great wedding anniversary idea! My husband and I were married in Key West 5 years ago, and just went on vacation back there. It is so neat to go back to places where you made your first memories with someone. You should have put something similar to the last picture on your wedding invitations. That would have been neat!
Saw your Webpage bookmarked on Reddit.I appreciate your web site and marketing technique. Check out my Farmville Guidebook in the event you get yourself a moment – I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.
This is what i am looking for! i appreciate your great effort so much. hope more and more people will love your article!just keep going!
The defensive line looked to be a six-player position all along, but the Cowboys kept seven, including promising tease Clifton Geathers(notes),
chi hair straightener http://www.chihairsonline.com
Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! By the way, how could we communicate?promof2012promof2012promof2012
So amazing! Finally i find the useful article here. Thanks for your sharing, i will watch your more blogs next time here.
There are many cheap dvds on sale on the web site :
http://www.dvdboxroom.com/
Thanks for your text, it was extremely interesting to read. I should like that you will add more pictures to your message. Write more about this topic, you are very know well the material. Also, visit mine website about tadalafil citrate: cheap tadalafil
I will be grateful if you continue this in future. Many people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!